All of you who are currently reading this post, might be very much into the happenings in the Financial Capital of India over the last few months as well as happenings in some of the states. Last few months I have made me rethink on lot of issues and perspectives and I thought why not write a post on them. And so here I have collated my thoughts over that last 3 days of Diwali break and trying to put them into logical sentences.
The media - print and visual has been agog with news about how one regional political leader in his bid to gain popularity is stoking fires of regionalism and sons of the soil issues and damaging the basic ethos of our pledge in school - "I am an Indian, India is my country; All Indians are my brothers and sisters ......... " I dont know if they take that pledge in school these days and if they do, does it have any importance at all. How can one gentleman say that if one has to stay in a particular state, he/she has to learn and live by that language, job preference is to be given to the localites and local customs are paramount. That is what rankles my conscience, my thoughts. Are we living in a dictatorship / Autocracy? What happened to India's plurality? The last few months has seen mindless violence and brutality towards the poor north Indian migrants (taxi drivers, roadside snacksellers and rickshaw drivers). One needs to look at this issue in the right perspective. Why and how did members of a particular community occupy certain professions (at the bottom of the social pyramid) in such a widespread manner. What were the local leaders and their cronies doing all this while? It would not be difficult to see it from the concepts of demand and supply and a vibrant democracy.
I have also observed a strange analogy between Bengal and Maharashtra. In Bengal, one would find the migrant labourers as Taxi Drivers, manual rickshaw pullers, civil construction labourers and porters at the railway station. Maharashtrians as with most Bengalis, like to earn their two pence, live a peaceful life, enjoy their fish curry & rice, and indulge in cultural pursuits (read theatre, music and art). Both the communities (the city dwellers) are not much attuned to hard manual labour. And probably thats where the so called "migrant" workforce filled up the gap. One would however need to consult a historian and anthropologist to find out the real reason.
But what is worrisome is what happens to people like us. Both me and my wife's parents have been in professions mandating them to travel to obscure places across the length and breadth of the country. We grew up in those places; different friends, different languages, different cultures, different food habits and different people to people warmth - assmilating all in the path of our growing up. My basic education was in an Institution which did not believe in religious and economic distinction. My higher education took me to a Southern state - staunch in its culture and warm in its embrace. My first profession as a soldier did not have any regional & religious identity. So what am I? Or what are we? Are we not sons of the soil? Which "Soil" are these leaders actually talking about here? There is now a raging National Issue. Central leaders creating pressure against the current regional activism; Pro regional lobbies creating anti pressure and the story goes on.
Its important that the common educated man realises that we are being stupid by being conned and its not the leaders. They are a smart bunch of people who knows that we have stopped thinking collectively, ethically and straight. The Marxists in Bengal stopped the teaching of English Language in school till Standard 6. The common refrain was again "cultural degradation". But surprisingly, the children of these leadres were all going to reputed convents across Kolkata (erstwhile Calcutta). I was agahst at seeing the Govt textbooks of Standard 6 teaching the student the basic alphabets of English. That was the mid 1980s. Cut across to 2008. Another state, another leader has raised the issue of regional identity. The children of such regional leaders though vouch by the international schools with astronomical fees. Some of them are also high profile real estate business men. A pertinent question that one should look into is how many of these real estate tycoons have actually contributed to something as socially relevant as "affordable housing" or any other socially relevant issues? Our infrastructure is not at all comparable to other countries of the BRIC nations, our healthcare system is relegated only to the cities and we have an education system which has almost nil practical utility. We are still harping and aiming at 8-9% GDP growth. How much of this growth really touches the 70 % of population which constitutes the have nots?
It leaves me all afraid. No regional identity as such and no political support existent. What do I give little Oindrilla (my daughter of 20 months) as legacy? Where does she stand in this divide of caste, regional identity, and religion identity? My caste has no reservation; I am not in my own linguistic region and I am not a religious minority. And neither do I have the financial muscle to send my daughter to the well heeled International schools, where the fees runs into lakhs of rupees per annum.
Are we paying a price being an educated, hardworking and nationalist Indian and not regional in mentality? India is not about religion, caste and region. India is about Oneness - the oneness of spirit and oneness of being together. I will hang on to the hope that things will change. We will be the change. Little Oindrilla will grow up here and grow up fine. If everyone of us starts thinking of being the change, we can bring in a revolution - a la KAIZEN (the Japanese concept of individual incremental change bringing in revolutionary change). Lets all ask for it.
Bouquets, brickbats and "no comments" welcome .....
The media - print and visual has been agog with news about how one regional political leader in his bid to gain popularity is stoking fires of regionalism and sons of the soil issues and damaging the basic ethos of our pledge in school - "I am an Indian, India is my country; All Indians are my brothers and sisters ......... " I dont know if they take that pledge in school these days and if they do, does it have any importance at all. How can one gentleman say that if one has to stay in a particular state, he/she has to learn and live by that language, job preference is to be given to the localites and local customs are paramount. That is what rankles my conscience, my thoughts. Are we living in a dictatorship / Autocracy? What happened to India's plurality? The last few months has seen mindless violence and brutality towards the poor north Indian migrants (taxi drivers, roadside snacksellers and rickshaw drivers). One needs to look at this issue in the right perspective. Why and how did members of a particular community occupy certain professions (at the bottom of the social pyramid) in such a widespread manner. What were the local leaders and their cronies doing all this while? It would not be difficult to see it from the concepts of demand and supply and a vibrant democracy.
I have also observed a strange analogy between Bengal and Maharashtra. In Bengal, one would find the migrant labourers as Taxi Drivers, manual rickshaw pullers, civil construction labourers and porters at the railway station. Maharashtrians as with most Bengalis, like to earn their two pence, live a peaceful life, enjoy their fish curry & rice, and indulge in cultural pursuits (read theatre, music and art). Both the communities (the city dwellers) are not much attuned to hard manual labour. And probably thats where the so called "migrant" workforce filled up the gap. One would however need to consult a historian and anthropologist to find out the real reason.
But what is worrisome is what happens to people like us. Both me and my wife's parents have been in professions mandating them to travel to obscure places across the length and breadth of the country. We grew up in those places; different friends, different languages, different cultures, different food habits and different people to people warmth - assmilating all in the path of our growing up. My basic education was in an Institution which did not believe in religious and economic distinction. My higher education took me to a Southern state - staunch in its culture and warm in its embrace. My first profession as a soldier did not have any regional & religious identity. So what am I? Or what are we? Are we not sons of the soil? Which "Soil" are these leaders actually talking about here? There is now a raging National Issue. Central leaders creating pressure against the current regional activism; Pro regional lobbies creating anti pressure and the story goes on.
Its important that the common educated man realises that we are being stupid by being conned and its not the leaders. They are a smart bunch of people who knows that we have stopped thinking collectively, ethically and straight. The Marxists in Bengal stopped the teaching of English Language in school till Standard 6. The common refrain was again "cultural degradation". But surprisingly, the children of these leadres were all going to reputed convents across Kolkata (erstwhile Calcutta). I was agahst at seeing the Govt textbooks of Standard 6 teaching the student the basic alphabets of English. That was the mid 1980s. Cut across to 2008. Another state, another leader has raised the issue of regional identity. The children of such regional leaders though vouch by the international schools with astronomical fees. Some of them are also high profile real estate business men. A pertinent question that one should look into is how many of these real estate tycoons have actually contributed to something as socially relevant as "affordable housing" or any other socially relevant issues? Our infrastructure is not at all comparable to other countries of the BRIC nations, our healthcare system is relegated only to the cities and we have an education system which has almost nil practical utility. We are still harping and aiming at 8-9% GDP growth. How much of this growth really touches the 70 % of population which constitutes the have nots?
It leaves me all afraid. No regional identity as such and no political support existent. What do I give little Oindrilla (my daughter of 20 months) as legacy? Where does she stand in this divide of caste, regional identity, and religion identity? My caste has no reservation; I am not in my own linguistic region and I am not a religious minority. And neither do I have the financial muscle to send my daughter to the well heeled International schools, where the fees runs into lakhs of rupees per annum.
Are we paying a price being an educated, hardworking and nationalist Indian and not regional in mentality? India is not about religion, caste and region. India is about Oneness - the oneness of spirit and oneness of being together. I will hang on to the hope that things will change. We will be the change. Little Oindrilla will grow up here and grow up fine. If everyone of us starts thinking of being the change, we can bring in a revolution - a la KAIZEN (the Japanese concept of individual incremental change bringing in revolutionary change). Lets all ask for it.
Bouquets, brickbats and "no comments" welcome .....
4 comments:
Regionalism in India worries me. Hope things get better.
Enjoyed the "Iyerization/Globalization" article. ;-)
Take care.
Couldn't agree with you more on this. We aren't Indians any more; we are bengalis, marathis, gujratis, telegus...The idea of forming states based on language has severly backfired. I have spent most of my life in Assam;I have seen regionalism in it's ugliest form, I was too young and wondered why being a bengali makes me a pariah. In my heart, I am as much as assamese as anyone else. Assam saw a mass exodus of Bengalis, people left their hearth and business and fled. Then having tired of bengalis, the focus shifted on north indians, a mass genocide, entire villages wiped out overnight, and people fled. Again. Hardworking people, all Indians, who have a constitutional right to work anywhere in the country. Jinnah had once famously said, "Assam will come to us in a silver platter. You don't have to work for it." Our Founding Fathers adopted a national language to bring forth unity in diversity, yet, venture down south and people are loath to communicate/learn hindi. Why do we behave the way we do? Why can't we see beyond our narrow boundaries? And what about casteism? Heavens help people belonging to the General Category. Actually it's quite easy blaming it all on the politians, and it makes sense too. They are all traitors of the country. But what about us? When did we get so divided? The mother of all democracy is now a sad joke. God help us.
India is a strange country...when in a Indo-Pak cricket match people get so united that at roads unofficial carfew toils....again let an Aneek Dhar go for Sa_Re-Ga-Ma-Pa types contest....whole Bengal will vote for him to win only..whether they like or dont...after all "banglar chele toh!!!"
India is strangely united and yet divided....
Future for our offsprings is scary....we in our colg days couldnt get admitted in good GOvt colleges getting more than 85% when our "Govt's Previledged Brahmins"[a term used by our Mass Comm teacher for the SC/ST/OBC's....my friends only got getting only early 50%... may parents were not that stinking rich so as to send me to some colg that takes a huge donation...and offers great placements...so where do i stand?
and most importantly where will our kids???
In television and in media there is this universal battle over "Real n Reel"
now it seems it has started in lives to as to what ought to be...and what actually is...!!!!
very nice fodder :P
I really like when people are expressing their opinion and thought. So I like the way you are writing
Post a Comment